Mincemeat Tarts with Butter Pastry Recipe

Mincemeat Tarts with Butter Pastry Recipe






Shares 3

There is one job that I happily hand over to Mr. Kitchen Magpie when it comes to holiday baking: the yearly making of mincemeat tarts. I learned early in our marriage that he has a deep abiding love for mincemeat tarts that stems from one of his fondest childhood memories. He has mastered making mincemeat tarts with butter pastry (a super easy recipe) and is sharing it today with all of you.

“Every year at Christmas my mom would make 2-3 dozen minced meat tarts and put them in old cookie tins in the fridge. It was always a race between my dad and I to get our own tin to hoard and eat over the holidays. We would sit there with our stolen tins watching TV with a huge glass of milk to wash it down. I can still see my Dad sitting in his recliner with his tarts. To this day, when minced meat tarts are made, I am very particular about how they look and are made, so I take over the making of tarts from Karlynn. There must be a small round top on the tart and they must be cold (mainly because when the tarts are fresh they fall apart, and I can’t cram the whole tart in my mouth). I basically live on these tarts for a few days until they are gone, then wait until Christmas rolls around next year!” Mike

So now mincemeat tarts and a glass of milk are a family tradition in our house for the holidays. I always have milk in my fridge, but during the holiday season I make sure to stock up with extra cartons. We usually have out of town company over on weekends – with kids that love their bowls of cereal & milk in the morning – and I make sure that at all times I have milk on hand.

And my Christmas baking? Holy Dinah, I can’t even guess how much milk I go through! We are truly lucky here in Canada to have delicious & refreshing Canadian quality milk that is part of our holiday season, whether it’s a cold glass of milk with dinner or milk as a staple used in our baking.

My love of milk during the holidays goes along perfectly with the most adorable Christmas video I have seen this year from the Dairy Farmers of Canada! My daughter and I are in love with the adorable little reindeer in it – try to watch the video full screen so you can see him properly!

You can also visit Dairy Farmers of Canada’s YouTube page to learn more about their commitment to making milk delicious and refreshing and for more ideas on incorporating milk into your holidays!

So, how is everyone doing with their Christmas baking so far? I always think that I am getting ahead of the game, but end up panicking at the last minute of course. What is going to be on your dessert trays this year?

Happy Baking everyone! Hope you enjoy Mr. Magpie’s recipe!


Karlynn and Mike

*While this post has been generously sponsored by Dairy Farmers of Canada, all my opinions remain my own. *

Pin this to your Christmas Baking Board!

PrintMincemeat Tarts with Butter PastryAuthor: Karlynn Johnston

Prep Time: 120 minutes

Cook Time: 20 minutes

Total Time: 2 hours 20 minutes

Yield: 24

Print Recipe

Pin Recipe


  • 2 ½ cups all-purpose flour
  • ½ tsp salt
  • 1 cup butter, frozen
  • 1 cup ice water
  • 1 jar of your favourite mincemeat filling
Read the whole recipe on The Kitchen Magpie